Perrier vs Seltzer

By | November 25, 2017

How is Perrier water different from seltzer water? Well, they both sparkle and bubble. And they both are water. Why is buying water seems to be so complicated today? There are different brands and labels that seem to bring unnecessary confusion to a simple task. Nevertheless, it does not change the fact that Perrier water is different from seltzer water. In this article, we will discuss on the things that make Perrier vs seltzer water different, along with the implications. For example, you can use seltzer water for your cocktail, but you may not want to use Perrier water for the same purpose.

What is Perrier Water?
Perrier water is a brand of natural bottled mineral water, or, more specifically, sparkling mineral water (take a look: Perrier vs Soda Water). This is because Perrier water is acquired from a natural spring. The carbonation is also acquired from the same natural spring. Compared to other sparkling mineral water products, Perrier water stands out because of the distinctive green bottle and higher carbonation level.

Perrier water is captured from a spring in Vergeze, which is located in the Gard departement, France. This spring is naturally carbonated, but the water and natural carbon dioxide are captured independently. The water is first purified before getting the carbon dioxide back during the bottling process. The carbonation level is made to match the original level in the Vergeze spring.

Perrier water is sold in distinctive teardrop-shaped bottles that have a signature green color, and also in cans. In addition to the original unflavored version, there are also several flavored variants such as lemon, lime, pink grapefruit, green apple, and mint.

What is Seltzer Water?
On the other hand, seltzer water is a type of carbonated water that does not contain any additional mineral. The big difference between Perrier vs seltzer water is the source. Seltzer water is “artificially” made, in a sense that the carbon dioxide is added to the plain water in a modern facility. The ingredients are not necessarily acquired from natural sources. And, unlike club soda, seltzer soda does not contain any added mineral, although some flavoring agents may be used to create flavored products. There are various brands of seltzer water on the market, such as Vintage, Canada Dry, Schweppes, and Polar.

Ingredients
The very first difference that sets Perrier vs seltzer water apart is the source. As explained above, Perrier water is a brand of sparkling mineral water, which means that it is acquired from a natural spring. Both the water and carbonation are collected from the Vergeze spring. On the other hand, seltzer water is not necessarily acquired from a natural spring; the water and carbonation can be acquired from other sources and synthetically.

Furthermore, there is also another difference between Perrier water and seltzer water regarding the ingredients. The minerals. Perrier water contains minerals such as salts and sulfur compounds. These minerals also come from the natural spring. On the other hand, seltzer water does not contain any mineral. It may only contain flavoring agents, such as lime or citrus.

Carbonation
The carbonation of Perrier water naturally occurs in the Vergeze spring. Although the water and carbon dioxide are captured independently, the carbonation level is matched to the original level in the spring. Compared to other similar products, the carbonation level of Perrier water is quite higher.

Read also:  Tea Bag vs Loose Leaf

The carbonation of seltzer water is done in the processing facility. The carbon dioxide gas does not necessarily come from a natural source. The carbonation levels may vary, depending on the brand, but the carbonation levels are generally lower than that of Perrier water.

Flavor
Perrier vs seltzer water has very different flavor. This is mostly because of the mineral content and carbonation level.

Perrier water has a noticeably heavier mouth feel due to the minerals it contains. It also has a very distinctive taste. The flavor is unique; you can expect different sparkling mineral water products to have different flavors, depending on where the water came from. It feels refreshing, and it “pops” in your mouth.

On the other hand, seltzer water is much, much lighter. This is because it does not contain any mineral. It has a neutral, clean taste. However, there are indeed some flavored products available with additional flavoring agents. It is also refreshing, but it does not sting very hard in the mouth.

Applications
Because of the different characteristics in ingredients and flavors, Perrier water and seltzer water are used for different purposes. In general, seltzer water is more versatile for different uses.

Perrier water has a distinctive flavor, so it cannot be added to a different liquid without altering the taste. In general Perrier water is suitable for everyday drinking. You drink it without adding any other liquid. Some people prefer to drink Perrier water with some lime. It is not recommended to be used in cocktails because of the flavor.

On the other hand, seltzer is suitable for everyday drinking as well as for cocktails. The clean and neutral flavor makes it suitable to be added to another liquid without altering the taste very much. It is a great substitute for club soda if you don’t like added sugar or minerals. You can pour it into your cocktails to add the bubbly effect.

Health Effects
Perrier water is not bad for your health if you only drink it every once in a while. Although it does not contain added sugar, keep in mind that it contains several minerals. The minerals can help you fulfill your daily nutritional requirements, but too much sodium is bad for your body. People with health conditions that require them to avoid sodium, calcium, or potassium should also be careful.

Seltzer water is also not bad if you don’t drink it too much. It does not contain any added sugar or mineral, so it is suitable for a wide range of people. Nevertheless, the carbonation may also cause oral issues, so don’t drink it too much.

Perrier WaterSeltzer Water
- Acquired from a natural spring in Vergeze- Made from manufacturing process
- Contains minerals- Does not contain minerals
- Distinctive taste with heavy mouth feel- Clean, neutral taste
- Not recommended for cocktails- Suitable for cocktails

Conclusion
Perrier water is acquired from a natural source, and it contains minerals. Perrier water has a distinctive taste, so it is not suitable for mixing with cocktails. Seltzer water does not necessarily come from a natural source. Seltzer water doesn’t contain minerals, hence the flavor is clean and neutral. Seltzer water is suitable for cocktails.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *